top of page

Net Zero Is the Law. Where is the Plan?

Writer: Lori Guetre
Lori Guetre
Nov 1
6 min read

Updated: Nov 3

As Canadians watch the trial in La Rose v. His Majesty the King, much of the discussion will focus on constitutional rights, climate science, and the role of the courts.


Those are important questions. The Court will decide them.


But outside the courtroom, I think there is a simpler question that every Canadian should be asking:


Canada has passed net zero into law. Where is the plan?


Not a vision. Not a strategy. Not a target.


A plan.


The kind that connects today’s emissions to the 2050 commitment through a visible, traceable pathway, and tells us which policies and regulations get us there.


Passing net zero into law answered the question of whether Canada intends to get there. Canadians still deserve to know how.


I am not a lawyer. I am a systems engineer. For most of my career, I worked on large aerospace systems and, for eight years, I worked in climate technology. What I see in this discussion is a question that appears in every major engineering project:


How do we know the proposed approach satisfies the requirement?


The aerospace systems we built often involved thousands of components, hundreds of interfaces, and countless technical risks. In systems engineering, we begin by defining the "what" before the "how." The requirements specify what the system must accomplish. The design explains how it will accomplish it.


The design didn't have to be perfect. Improvements would be proposed. Assumptions would change. Risks would be assessed. Tradeoffs would have to be made. But the relationship between the requirement and the proposed solution had to be visible and traceable. The purpose of a design review was not to determine whether a system was flawless; it was to determine whether the proposed design was complete and whether it could reasonably be expected to meet the requirement.


If we had a requirement but could not show how the system design was expected to satisfy it, the design review would stop right there.


Canada's legal commitment to achieve net zero emissions by 2050 is a requirement – the “what”.

As an engineer, that immediately raises a question:


Where is the plan? 


To be clear, the issue is not that Canada lacks climate targets or planning documents. The issue is whether Canadians can see how today’s policies, investments, regulations, technologies, and assumptions collectively add up to a complete, traceable pathway to net zero by 2050.


Canada’s own Long-Term Strategy, filed with the United Nations in 2022, is explicit on this: it states that it “is not a climate plan” nor is it “a blueprint for action.” Without a plan, Canadians cannot independently assess at the outset whether the country is on track to fulfill its legal commitment - and cannot track whether it stays on track as the decades unfold.


There are many possible shapes a pathway to net zero could take. Each pathway has very different implications for investment, infrastructure, workforce, and risk. The chart below shows three illustrative examples alongside Canada’s legislated interim targets for 2030 and 2035 (red bars). A smooth decline (blue). A later, steeper decline (purple). A path that rises before it falls (orange).


Line chart showing Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions from 1990 to 2024 (rising from about 600 to a peak near 780 megatonnes, then settling near 685 Mt), followed by three illustrative dashed pathways to zero by 2050: a smooth decline, a later steeper decline, and a path that rises before it falls. Red vertical bars mark Canada’s 2030 and 2035 target bands; none of the three illustrative pathways meets both.

Illustrative pathways from Canada’s 2024 emissions (~685 Mt CO₂e) to net zero in 2050. Red bars show Canada’s legislated interim targets: 408-445 Mt in 2030 (40-45% below 2005) and 371-408 Mt in 2035 (45-50% below 2005). The illustrative pathways are shapes, not forecasts.


This is not an argument that any of these shapes is right or wrong. It is an argument that the shape and completeness of the plan matter. Plotting the information in a clear, transparent way lets Canadians see what’s going on and pose questions, like:


a) Even the aggressive blue line doesn’t meet both of Canada’s interim targets for 2030 and 2035.  What is the plan to hit the legislated targets?


b) If Canada continues to approve unabated natural gas plants to power the data centre queue (over 19 gigawatts in Alberta alone) and ends up on the orange trajectory, what is the plan to accelerate emissions reductions elsewhere to compensate for these increases?


The Net-Zero Advisory Body - the independent body established under the Act to advise the government - found in its third annual report that even with its recommended policy enhancements layered on top of currently legislated measures, Canada would reach at most a 28% reduction below 2005 levels by 2030 and 31% by 2035, well short of the legislated 40-45% and 45-50% targets. The shortfall is significant, but it’s only part of the puzzle - until Canada publishes a clear plan to 2050 and shows how it plans to achieve the trajectory, Canadians can’t assess whether we’re on track, where we’re drifting, or what it would take to close the gap.


What makes the absence of a visible pathway particularly frustrating is that this is no longer a problem waiting on invention. For decades, people around the world have been developing the technologies and approaches needed to reduce emissions and permanently remove carbon. Those technologies continue to improve and become even more affordable. This is also no longer unaffordable. The practical impact on today’s consumer is that most things will cost about 2% more as we stop leaving behind greenhouse gases for future generations to clean up. Over time, solving for net zero will save five to ten times the amount of money that it will cost us to continue to react and adapt to a changing climate.  


The clean infrastructure work ahead is still substantial and will take decades. But we are no longer waiting for a breakthrough. We are waiting for a plan.


Every complex undertaking needs a plan. Driving from Vancouver to Halifax needs a plan. Hosting holiday dinner for 12 needs a plan. Building an aircraft needs a plan.


Getting to net zero is no different.


Four side-by-side panels, each pairing a goal with a planning checklist. From left: a map of Canada with a dashed route from Vancouver to Halifax; a roast turkey on a platter; an airplane; and the words “Net Zero.” The first three panels show a filled checklist beside each goal. The fourth panel shows a faded checklist with a question mark over it.

Every complex undertaking needs a plan.

 

A reasonable citizen should be able to ask:

  • What emissions remain today, and where do they come from?

  • What pathway is expected to reduce them to net zero by 2050?

  • How does that pathway meet Canada’s 2030 and 2035 targets along the way?

  • What assumptions does the pathway rely on, and what are the main risks?

  • How will Canadians know whether the country is on track?

  • If Canada falls off track, what corrective actions will be taken?


These are not political questions. They are planning questions. And they are normal questions.

If Parliament established a legal requirement to provide safe drinking water or aviation safety, Canadians would reasonably expect a plan they could read and assess for themselves. One that qualified experts had developed, reviewed, tested, and updated over time.


Other jurisdictions have gone further. The United Kingdom’s independent Climate Change Committee publishes successive carbon budgets accompanied by a sectoral pathway running from today to net zero in 2050, which Parliament then legislates. Switzerland has written sector-level emission targets into law. Germany sets legally binding annual sectoral emissions budgets, with mandatory corrective action when a sector falls short. (Germany and Switzerland have gone one step further, committing in law to net-negative emissions after 2050 – beginning to draw their historical emissions out of the atmosphere.) The design choices in each of these pathways can be debated. Their existence cannot.


A complete pathway does more than improve transparency. It creates the foundation for improvement. Once a design exists, people can debate whether it is too expensive, too slow, too risky, or insufficiently ambitious. They can suggest better alternatives, identify gaps, and correct mistakes.


It also allows Canadians to see whether the country is staying broadly aligned with its major trading partners or drifting toward policies and timelines that could create future competitiveness challenges, including exposure to carbon border adjustment mechanisms and other trade measures.


You cannot optimize a plan that has never been shown.


In school, students are asked to show their work. Engineers do the same thing through requirements, assumptions, analyses, risk assessments, verification activities, and test results. The purpose is not to prove that we are right; it is to allow others to assess whether our conclusions are reasonable.


A legal requirement without a transparent, testable pathway is not a strategy. It is an aspiration.

This is why the plaintiffs' requested remedy, a Climate Recovery Plan, makes sense to me. Not because it dictates climate policy, but because every country serious about net zero should already have a complete, transparent, and testable plan showing how that commitment is expected to be fulfilled.


As a systems engineer and a Canadian, my view is simple: if the plaintiffs win, Canada should have a plan. If the plaintiffs lose, Canada should have a plan. If the case had never been filed, Canada should have a plan.


The courts will decide on the case. Parliament and governments will continue to choose policies. Those are their respective roles.


But Canadians should not need a court order to see how a legal commitment is expected to be achieved.


That is simply good governance.


Where is the plan? Show us the work.

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

© Possible by Design, CC BY 4.0.

Contents may be shared and adapted with attribution.

bottom of page