top of page

Humanity Has Solved Collective Harms Before. Now International Law Requires It for Climate.

Writer: Lori Guetre
Lori Guetre
Nov 7
4 min read

Updated: Nov 13

We are much closer than I thought.


In July 2025, the International Court of Justice clarified what international law now requires of every country on climate. The standard is strict. The obligation is binding. The pattern is known. And humanity has solved collective environmental harms using this pattern before - more than once.


The difference is that in every previous case, countries acted before international law required them to. For climate, international law has arrived first.


Here is what that pattern looks like, and what it says about what good now looks like for climate.


Diagram showing the recurring pattern used to solve collective environmental harms through regulation, innovation, enforcement, and legally binding targets.

What just changed


In July 2025, the International Court of Justice issued its Advisory Opinion on Obligations of States in Respect of Climate Change. States (countries) now carry a binding duty to exercise stringent due diligence by taking all means at their disposal to prevent significant harm to the climate system from greenhouse gas emissions. Where private actors are the source of emissions, the duty extends to taking necessary regulatory and legislative measures to limit them. Failure may constitute an internationally wrongful act. The operative part of the opinion was adopted unanimously by all 15 judges.


In May 2026, the United Nations General Assembly endorsed the opinion by a vote of 141 in favour, 8 against, and 28 abstaining.


The opinion itself is formally non-binding, but it clarifies what customary international law requires. Customary international law binds all countries, whether or not they have signed a treaty on the subject. When the ICJ clarifies what it requires, it is identifying law that already binds every country in the world. It is the underlying customary law that binds countries - and the ICJ has now made it clear that climate is subject to it.


The court also clarified that 1.5°C, not 2°C, is the agreed primary temperature goal under the Paris Agreement. Every country’s climate action is now legally evaluated against the 1.5°C benchmark.


Humanity has solved collective harms before


Countries have been solving collective environmental harms together for the last half century. Ozone depletion. Leaded gasoline. Acid rain. Smog. Mercury. Persistent organic pollutants. Asbestos. Ocean dumping. Transboundary hazardous waste.


Each was identified as a serious harm. Each was then addressed through a recognizable pattern: name the substance or activity, find solutions, agree on comprehensive regulatory coverage, set a binding timeline toward an endpoint, enforce, review, correct.


Where the pattern was fully applied, it worked. Ozone depletion was solved within a decade of the Montreal Protocol entering into force in developed economies - the Protocol has since been ratified by every country in the world, the only UN treaty to achieve universal ratification. Leaded gasoline was fully phased out globally by July 2021. Acid rain was substantially solved in the U.S., Canada, and Europe. Mercury, persistent organic pollutants, and transboundary hazardous waste are all in progress with strong trajectories.


Climate change joins this list of collective harms, with one important difference. In every prior case, countries chose to act before they were legally required to. For climate, international law has arrived first.


The sequencing has flipped. Historically, countries built the solution and law followed. With climate, the legal obligation is already here, and countries must now build the solution quickly enough to satisfy it.


What good now looks like


If the pattern has worked in every prior case where it was applied, and the climate obligation now requires all means at their disposal under stringent due diligence, what would a climate response that fully reflects that obligation look like?


The recipe has four key ingredients:

  • Comprehensive regulatory coverage of emissions. Named inventory, sector by sector, with binding timelines

  • Technical standards for abatement pathways. Certified pathways by sector, so compliance is verifiable and capital has signals it can deploy against

  • Transparency at every decision point. Producers, consumers, and regulators need to see the climate footprint of what they produce, buy, and regulate

  • An honest endpoint. Geological net zero - residual fossil CO₂ emissions matched one-for-one with permanent geological storage


The economics are settled: approximately 2% more on most products today to solve for net zero, and savings over time of five to ten times the cost of climate action compared with a future in which we keep reacting and adapting to a changing climate. The technology is settled: the pathways exist and are deployable. The legal question is now settled: the obligation is binding.


Three quiet shifts have snuck up on us


The legal shift is one of three developments that have quietly changed the climate picture in recent years. All three - technological, economic, and legal - have snuck up on us.


  • The technology for getting to net zero has only recently become viable at scale.

  • The economics of the transition has resolved at a modest cost today (about 2% more on most products) and large savings over time.

  • The law has now clarified that rapid action is required.


The reality has moved faster than perception on all three.


What this changes


For decades, climate advocacy has worked from the bottom up - persuading governments through accumulated public demand because there was no higher authority requiring action. That is no longer the only pathway. A binding international obligation now operates from the top, complementing decades of bottom-up pressure. Advocacy can now evaluate government conduct against a legal standard, name gaps where they exist, and demand swift action that the law already requires.


International law has moved first, but it doesn’t act on its own. If the ICJ’s clarification is to shape decisions in Canada - approvals, budgets, plans - governments need to hear from the people who elected them. Not just that we care about climate, but that we expect a real plan built to the new standard, with yearly tracking anyone can follow. This isn’t just a matter for international courts. It’s ours to carry too.


The work ahead is to help country governments hear what the law now requires - and to show them what good swift action looks like, so they can build it.


One way to start: include this sentence in your next letter or email.



  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

© Possible by Design, CC BY 4.0.

Contents may be shared and adapted with attribution.

bottom of page